Clear broth and a great soup: the rules cooks know
Why broth turns cloudy and how to clear it with egg white, whether to start meat in cold or hot water, how long to simmer chicken and beef, the order to add vegetables, how to keep borscht bright red and make a silky cream soup.
Cold or hot water
It depends on what you want. For a rich broth, put the meat and bones into cold water and heat slowly: proteins and flavour gradually move into the liquid. If juicy meat matters more than the broth, drop the meat into boiling water: the surface sets fast and keeps the juices in.
For a classic soup you almost always want the first option: cold water, slow heat.
Broth ratios
The best broth comes from meat on the bone: bones, cartilage and joints release gelatine — that rich, lip-sticking body. Boneless fillet gives a thin broth.
- Chicken: 1 kg chicken (backs, wings, thighs) to 2.5 l water, 1–1.5 hours.
- Beef: 1 kg bone-in beef to 3 l water, 3–4 hours.
- Pork: 1 kg ribs or hock to 3 l water, 2–2.5 hours.
- Vegetable: 1 kg vegetables (onion, carrot, celery, parsley root, mushroom stalks) to 2 l water, 40–50 minutes.
Why broth turns cloudy
Cloudiness is tiny bits of coagulated protein and emulsified fat. You get it for two reasons: the scum wasn't skimmed, and the broth boiled hard. A rolling boil literally whips fat and water into an emulsion, like mayonnaise.
The rule: as soon as it comes to the boil, skim all the foam and turn the heat right down — the surface should barely tremble, with the odd bubble at the edge. Leave the lid ajar.
- Skim before the boil — as the foam rises in a cap.
- Salt at the end: salt early speeds up protein leaching into the water.
- Don't stir the broth — it lifts the sediment from the bottom.
- Strain through a sieve lined with muslin or kitchen paper.
How to clear a cloudy broth
An old restaurant trick is the egg-white raft. The white coagulates and, like a filter, traps all the fine particles.
For 2 litres of broth take 1–2 egg whites. Whisk them with a glass of cooled broth. Bring the strained broth to a gentle simmer, pour in the egg mixture, stir once and then leave it alone. Keep it on the lowest heat for 15–20 minutes — the white will gather into flakes on the surface. Strain through muslin.
When to add vegetables
Vegetables for flavouring the broth (onion, carrot, celery) go in whole 40–60 minutes before the end and then get thrown away — they've given their taste and become bland. Vegetables for the soup go in according to cooking time so everything is tender at once.
- Diced potato — 15–20 minutes.
- Sliced carrot — 10–15 minutes if not sautéed.
- Fresh cabbage — 10–15 minutes; sauerkraut — 30–40.
- Grains: rice — 15–18 minutes, buckwheat — 15, pearl barley — cook separately in advance.
- Noodles — 5–7 minutes; herbs — at the very end, off the heat.
The sauté: flavour you shouldn't skip
Onion and carrot cooked in oil for 7–10 minutes until golden give a soup depth. This isn't calories for their own sake: fat dissolves aromatic compounds that don't open up in water. Use 1 onion and 1 carrot per 2–2.5 l of soup and 2 tbsp oil.
Add 1 tbsp tomato paste to the sauté and cook it for 1–2 minutes — the sweetness deepens and the raw taste disappears.
Borscht: keeping the colour bright
Beetroot's red is the pigment betanin. It breaks down with long boiling and in alkaline conditions but is stable in acid. That's why the beet is stewed separately with acid and added at the end.
Grate 1–2 beetroots (300–400 g for 3 l of borscht) and stew them in oil for 10–15 minutes with 1 tbsp 9% vinegar or the juice of half a lemon and 1 tsp sugar. Add to the nearly finished borscht, bring to the boil and switch off at once. Let it stand for 20–30 minutes.
Cream soup: a silky texture
The base is vegetables cooked until completely soft plus a little liquid. Add the liquid gradually while blending: thinning a thick soup is easy, thickening a thin one is not.
For velvetiness you need fat: per 1 l of soup, 100 ml of 20% cream or 30 g butter stirred in at the end. For smoothness, push the soup through a sieve — that's the difference between homely and restaurant.
Fill a jug blender no more than a third full with hot soup and hold the lid down with a towel: steam expands suddenly and can blow the lid off.
Salt and final touches
A typical amount is 1 tsp (6–7 g) of salt per litre of soup, but salt at the end and taste: broth reduces, and sausage, cheese or sauerkraut bring their own salt.
If a soup tastes flat but has enough salt, it's missing acid. A teaspoon of lemon juice or vinegar for the whole pot brightens it. Soup is better the next day, once the flavours have married.
- Fridge — up to 3 days in a covered pot.
- Freezer — up to 3 months (without potato and noodles: they turn woolly).
- Cool it quickly: stand the pot in a sink of cold water for 20–30 minutes.
Questions and answers
Should I throw away the first water?+
For beef and pork bones you can: bring to the boil, boil 5 minutes, drain, rinse the bones and cover with fresh cold water. The broth will be cleaner. For chicken, careful skimming is enough.
Why is my soup too salty when I salted it as usual?+
Most likely you salted at the start and the broth reduced by a quarter. Salt in the last 10 minutes.
Why did the potato fall apart?+
A floury variety or pieces cut too small. Use waxy, yellow-fleshed potatoes, cut into 1.5–2 cm cubes and don't cook longer than 20 minutes.
Can I make broth in a slow cooker?+
Yes — the stew setting gives exactly the gentle simmer you need, and the broth comes out clear. Timing is the same as on the hob.
How do I remove excess fat?+
Chill the broth: the fat sets into a crust that lifts off with a spoon. On hot broth, drag a sheet of kitchen paper across the surface.
Try it in practice
More kitchen secrets
A stress-free celebration meal: how much to cook, what to make ahead and how to get it all done
How many starters, salads, mains and drinks you need per guest, how to balance the menu, a prep plan from a week out to an hour before guests arrive, how to share one oven between dishes and which dishes can be made ahead. Plus safety: how long salads can sit on the table.
Read the articleMince: burgers, meatballs, cabbage rolls and meatloaf — the rules for each
What fat content mince needs for juiciness, why burger mince isn't salted in advance while meatball mix is kneaded. The panade secret, burgers that don't balloon, meatballs in sauce, cabbage rolls and stuffed peppers, meatloaf and freezing mince properly.
Read the articleNo-bake desserts: gelatine, agar, panna cotta and mousses that hold their shape
How much gelatine per litre for jelly, panna cotta and mousse, why gelatine must never boil and which fruits stop it setting. Agar instead of gelatine, stable whipped cream, a biscuit base for cheesecake and how to turn a dessert out cleanly.
Read the article